Podpower Episode Atlas

Overview

This episode of Unchained features host Laura Shin interviewing Alex Cutler, CEO and co-founder of Dramos Labs, about the recent launch of tokenized stocks on Coinbase's Base network. Cutler explains how these new tokenized assets differ significantly from previous versions, offering true beneficial ownership backed one-to-one by actual shares held by a regulated custodian, akin to the gold standard of traditional ETFs.

The conversation delves into the technical and economic implications of these tokenized stocks, highlighting their 24/7 global accessibility, lower costs, and composability within the DeFi ecosystem. Cutler shares impressive early volume statistics, noting that these on-chain markets are already exhibiting price discovery even when traditional markets are closed, as demonstrated by Nvidia's earnings announcement. He emphasizes that this innovation allows anyone to participate in market making, democratizing access to financial instruments previously dominated by large institutions.

Shin and Cutler also discuss the challenges and risks, particularly regarding price oracles and potential dislocations when underlying traditional markets are closed. Cutler argues that this 24/7 price discovery is a feature, not a bug, and that on-chain liquidity will increasingly become the primary source for pricing. The episode concludes with a look at the regulatory landscape in the US, Coinbase's efforts to gain SEC exemptions, and the ambitious vision for bringing 10% of global GDP on-chain within five years, with tokenized stocks playing a crucial role.

Themes

Tokenized Stocks / Exploring the paradigm shift in tokenized assets, moving from synthetic derivatives to true beneficial ownership of real-world stocks on-chain.DeFi Composability / Discussing how programmable tokenized stocks integrate with DeFi protocols, enabling new financial products and services.Market Democratization / Highlighting how 24/7 on-chain markets empower individuals to participate in market making and access assets previously limited by traditional finance.Price Discovery / Examining how on-chain markets can facilitate continuous price discovery, even when traditional exchanges are closed, impacting asset valuation.Regulatory Landscape / Addressing the challenges and potential future of tokenized stocks within the US regulatory environment, particularly concerning SEC exemptions.

Key Concepts

01

Beneficial Ownership (Tokenized Stocks)

Unlike previous synthetic tokenized assets, the new Coinbase tokenized stocks represent actual beneficial ownership of the underlying share, backed one-to-one by a regulated custodian.

Why careThis distinction is crucial for adoption and functional parity with traditional markets, providing true claims to the asset rather than just a derivative.

02

24/7 On-Chain Markets

On-chain markets for tokenized stocks operate continuously, unlike traditional markets that adhere to 'banker's hours,' enabling constant trading and price discovery.

Why careThis continuous operation allows for immediate reaction to news and events, potentially leading to more efficient and responsive markets.

03

Price Discovery (On-Chain)

On-chain markets can discover prices even when traditional markets are closed, as seen with Nvidia's earnings, where millions in volume poured in and the price rose before traditional markets reopened.

Why careThis suggests that on-chain markets could become the primary venue for price discovery, influencing how assets are valued globally.

04

Composability in DeFi

Tokenized stocks are programmable and composable, meaning they can be integrated with various DeFi protocols for lending, leveraged positions, and automated portfolios.

Why careThis unlocks new financial use cases and products that are not possible in traditional finance, enhancing utility and accessibility.

05

Off-Chain Multiplier

For dividends and stock splits, an off-chain multiplier is used to adjust the value of the tokenized stock, reflecting these events without changing the on-chain token count.

Why careThis mechanism allows tokenized stocks to accurately reflect the economic benefits of holding traditional shares while maintaining on-chain tradability.

06

Permissionless Market Making

The open nature of on-chain markets allows anyone to participate in market making, providing liquidity and earning fees, democratizing a role traditionally held by large institutions.

Why careThis increases market efficiency, reduces costs, and opens up new opportunities for individuals to earn yield from financial activities.

Quotes

"What these markets are going to allow people to do is anyone can now be Ken Griffin, right? They can come on chain and they can participate in the very act of market making in a really incredible way."
guest Alex Cutler explains the democratizing power of on-chain markets for tokenized stocks.
"What Coinbase launched is a paradigm shift moment. You know, I think this is leaping far ahead of the solutions we've seen because it is fundamentally a representation of the actual underlying asset in the stock."
guest Alex Cutler describes the significance of Coinbase's approach to tokenized stocks, emphasizing true asset representation.
3:05
"In our opinion, price dislocations when markets are closed is the feature, not the bug of these tokenized onchain markets."
guest Alex Cutler argues that 24/7 on-chain price discovery, even when traditional markets are closed, is a beneficial characteristic.
19:27
"The tokens themselves are still permissionless and accessible and composable across DeFi. But for the full experience, say I wanted to take my Apple shares and I wanted to vote in a issue that was being brought up for Apple shareholders to vote on. I might need to go do that on Cobase.com, you know, with my KYC."
guest Alex Cutler explains the potential dual nature of tokenized stocks in the US, balancing permissionless DeFi use with KYC-gated full ownership rights.
26:35
"Brian Armstrong said, Coinbase's belief is that in the next five years, we will bring 10% of global GDP onchain. And I think that seemed a little crazy to folks when he said that on an earnings call."
guest Alex Cutler references Brian Armstrong's ambitious vision for the future of on-chain finance.
29:40

Chapters

010:00Democratizing Market Making with Tokenized StocksAlex Cutler introduces the concept of tokenized stocks enabling anyone to become a market maker, drawing parallels to content creation on the internet.021:01Coinbase's Paradigm Shift in Tokenized StocksAlex explains how Coinbase's tokenized stocks offer true beneficial ownership, unlike previous synthetic versions, making them a 'gold standard'.034:06Early Volume & On-Chain Price DiscoveryAlex shares impressive early trading volumes for tokenized stocks on Aerodrome and discusses how on-chain markets are already facilitating 24/7 price discovery, as seen with Nvidia's earnings.048:12The Mechanics of True Beneficial OwnershipAlex details the backend setup of Coinbase's tokenized stocks, emphasizing their beneficial trust structure and how they handle dividends and stock splits via an off-chain multiplier.0513:16Tokenized Stocks in DeFi: Composability & AccessAlex discusses how tokenized stocks integrate with DeFi protocols, offering access to assets and market making opportunities that undercut traditional brokers' high profit margins.0618:27Risks & Opportunities of 24/7 TradingLaura and Alex discuss the risks of price dislocation when traditional markets are closed, with Alex arguing that on-chain price discovery is a feature, not a bug, and how Chainlink oracles are adapting.0723:33US Regulatory Landscape & SEC ExemptionsThe conversation shifts to the US regulatory environment, Coinbase's SEC innovation exemption application, and what tokenized stocks might look like for US users.0827:37Future Expansion & On-Chain GDP VisionAlex outlines plans for adding more tokenized assets and real-world assets to Aerodrome, aligning with Coinbase's vision to bring 10% of global GDP on-chain.

Take-Aways

  • 01Coinbase's tokenized stocks on Base represent actual beneficial ownership of underlying shares, a significant advancement over previous synthetic versions.
  • 02These on-chain markets operate 24/7, enabling continuous trading and price discovery even when traditional markets are closed.
  • 03Early trading volumes for tokenized stocks on Aerodrome have been substantial, demonstrating strong market interest and adoption.
  • 04The composability of tokenized stocks within DeFi allows for innovative financial products and services, such as leveraged LP positions and automated portfolios.
  • 05On-chain markets for tokenized stocks can democratize market making, allowing individuals to participate in activities traditionally dominated by large institutions.
  • 06The ability of on-chain markets to discover prices independently, as seen with Nvidia's earnings, suggests a future where they lead global asset valuation.
  • 07Coinbase is actively working with regulators like the SEC to bring tokenized equities to US users, potentially through a hybrid model balancing permissionless DeFi with KYC-gated features.

Open Questions

  • ?How do Coinbase's new tokenized stocks on Base fundamentally differ from previous tokenized asset versions?
  • ?What impact do 24/7 on-chain markets have on price discovery, especially when traditional markets are closed?
  • ?How can tokenized stocks be utilized within the DeFi ecosystem, and what new financial products do they enable?
  • ?What are the risks associated with trading tokenized stocks on-chain, particularly regarding price oracles and liquidity during off-market hours?
  • ?What is the current regulatory outlook for tokenized stocks in the US, and how might they be made available to US users?
  • ?What is the long-term vision for bringing real-world assets, including stocks and FX, onto the blockchain economy?

Glossary

Beneficial Ownership
The right to enjoy the benefits of ownership of an asset, even if the legal title is held by another party.
AMM (Automated Market Maker)
A type of decentralized exchange protocol that relies on mathematical formulas to price assets, rather than an order book.
Composability
The ability of different DeFi protocols and assets to seamlessly integrate and interact with each other, creating new functionalities.
Price Oracle
A service that feeds real-world data, such as asset prices, onto a blockchain for use by smart contracts.
TVL (Total Value Locked)
The total value of cryptocurrency assets deposited in a DeFi protocol, often used as a metric for its popularity and liquidity.
RFQ (Request for Quote)
A process where a buyer requests quotes from multiple sellers for a specific product or service, common in over-the-counter trading.

People Mentioned

Stephen Spielberg
Mentioned as an example of traditional content creation, contrasting with the democratized content creation enabled by the internet.
Jesse Pollock
Founder of Base, whose vision for building the most vibrant capital market in history is cited by Alex Cutler.
Ken Griffin
CEO of Citadel, used as an example of a traditional market maker, contrasting with the democratized market making enabled by on-chain finance.
Brian Armstrong
CEO of Coinbase, whose ambitious goal of bringing 10% of global GDP on-chain within five years is discussed.

Pull A Thread

  • Coinbase's Base network and its ecosystem
  • Dramos Labs and Aerodrome Finance
  • The concept of real-world asset (RWA) tokenization
  • Chainlink's role in providing price oracles for DeFi
  • The regulatory landscape for digital assets in the United States, particularly SEC rulings on tokenized securities
Podpower / Atlas / 8075668